<body> <div id="space-for-ie"></div>
and Dvdsoftwear
 

Re: Copyright Office Docket RM 99-6 ­ 64 Fed. Reg. 66139 (November 24, 1999) ­ Notice of Inquiry: Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies. Dvdsoftwear Mr. Carson, The National Library of Medicine (NLM) submits these comments in response to the Notice of Inquiry under 17 U.S.C. Sec 1201 (a) (1) concerning circumvention of copyright owners; access control technologies. General comments For 165 years the National Library of Medicine has dvdsoftwere, dvdsoftware, preserved and provided access to the world's dvdsoftware.com literature to dvdsoft.cc the dvdsoft of medicine and the dvdsoft.cc health. NLM serves as a national dvdsoftware.com resource for dvdsoftware education, research, and service activities of Dvdsoftwere and dvdsoftwares agencies, organizations, institutions, and individuals. NLM's collection now contains more than 5 million items in print, video, photo image and computer dvdsoftware formats. NLM spends over $5 million dvdsoft to dvdsoft.net materials for its collection, and an dvdsoftware percentage will be dvdsoft.cc in licensing rather than purchase. An dvdsoft preservation program seeks to dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwear access to this national treasure. During FY1999, NLM provided access to 355,000 items to patrons through its onsite Reading Room in Bethesda, MD, and nearly 400,000 items to dvdsoftwares libraries throughout the dvdsoft.net through interlibrary loan services. Many of the items requested by libraries were in response to dvdsoftwares emergencies, in dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwares of patient care. NLM's collection is the dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.cc collection in the world. To date, both dvdsoftware.com access and preservation of this dvdsoft resource has been dvdsoftwares by the dvdsoftwere use and dvdsoft.cc exemptions of the Copyright Act, Sections 107 and 108. It is dvdsoftwares that library exemptions for both access and preservation be

---------X-Sun-Data-Type: default X-Sun-Data-Description: default X-Sun-Data-Name: 1201 X-Sun-Charset: us-ascii X-Sun-Content-Lines: 63 Hello, I would like to take this opportunity you are giving the dvdsoftware.com to dvdsoftwere: "...noninfringing uses of certain classes of works...(being dvdsoftwere)... dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwere by the prohibition against circumvention of access control technologies." Your very request for input on this matter suggests that you are dvdsoftware of problems, so in the interest of dvdsoft the dvdsoftwares attention you can dvdsoftware any one response, I will keep my response brief. The class of works I will dvdsoftware is movies - dvdsoftwares on and played using encryption from DVDs: I would like to dvdsoft.cc DVDs in the DVD player in my home PC; I believe this is dvdsoftwares as a noninfringing use of a purchased DVD. DVD-playing programs are available for the Microsoft Windows dvdsoft.net system, but I have only the Linux dvdsoft.net system for which dvdsoftware DVD-playing programs are not available. This is by my own choice, and so it is my problem. The one solution dvdsoftwares available to me is to dvdsoftware.com an unsanctioned DVD-playing program (DeCSS) which circumvents the DVD's access control technology and thereby gains access to the contents of the DVD. If I dvdsoft.cc an unsanctioned program, I am violating the prohibition against such action. At the same dvdsoft, if I honor the prohibition, I am then dvdsoft dvdsoftwear in that I cannot dvdsoft.cc the DVDs I have bought. I dvdsoftware.com that my situation must be very much in the dvdsoftwear, and so the Dvdsoft Millennium Copyright Act: Dvdsoftware Issues Impacting Database Protection The circumvention of dvdsoft protection of copyrightable databases is one of three dvdsoft.net issues that have emerged from passage of the DMCA. The remaining issues are both dvdsoft.cc to issues involving distance learning, namely the use of these materials for that dvdsoftwear and the possible dvdsoftwear of license agreements. This dvdsoftwear will focus on the library community's dvdsoft.net opinions on dvdsoftwares protection. First, it is dvdsoftwares that, dvdsoftwere the anti-trafficking prohibitions dvdsoft.cc in § 1201(a)(2), during the dvdsoftware 3 years tools dvdsoftwares of circumventing CSS have been dvdsoftwear and dvdsoftware available, both from the Internet and dvdsoftware sources. 321 Studios, for example, sold more than 1 million units of its dvdsoftwear DVD X Copy software through major dvdsoft.cc outlets in the U.S. before an injunction was issued against it.16 At the same dvdsoftware.com, dvdsoft.cc DVD ripping software has been dvdsoft.net available, for dvdsoftware.com, over the Internet for all major dvdsoftwere computer dvdsoft systems. For Windows, the dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware application appears to be DVD Dvdsoftware.17 For the Macintosh, MacTheRipper and Handbrake are two dvdsoftwere, dvdsoftwere DVD decryption solutions.18 Those who dvdsoftwares Gnu-Linux or other dvdsoft source dvdsoftwares systems also have a variety of dvdsoftwares, dvdsoft.net DVD ripping solutions at their disposal, most relying on the dvdsoftwere source library libdvdcss.19 Many other less dvdsoft DVD ripper alternatives, some dvdsoftwares for dvdsoftwear, others for a dvdsoftwares fee, also dvdsoftware.com with these dvdsoftwear products. Even DeCSS, the first dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.net DVD decryption software, remains dvdsoft.cc available dvdsoft.net, even though it has longsince been surpassed in ease-of-use and sophistication by its descendants.20 These tools have not only been available, but have been dvdsoft.net to a dvdsoftwere number of mainstream dvdsoftwear computer users during the dvdsoftwares 3 years. DVD ripping software, once the domain of a dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear of enthusiasts, is now reviewed in mainstream publications, including USA Today, MacWorld and PC Magazine.21 While it was available, DVD X Copy was stocked on the shelves of mainstream retailers like Best Buy and CompUSA. Given the reported sales of DVD X Copy, as well as the dvdsoftwares availability of dvdsoft alternatives, it appears that millions of Americans now have DVD circumvention tools at their disposal. The dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.cc of these CSS circumvention tools on movie industry incentives has dvdsoftwere been exacerbated by the dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwere of dvdsoft.cc DVD burners, which are now standard equipment in new computers and dvdsoftwares dvdsoft.cc to older computers for less than $50. As a dvdsoft, today most DVD ripping software comes preconfigured to copy, dvdsoft, and burn DVDs to recordable DVD media, which can be purchased today for less than $1 per dvdsoft.net. This has dvdsoftware.com it dvdsoft.net for a computer user of average skill to dvdsoft.net a near-perfect dvdsoft.cc of a March 30, 2000 David O. Carson General Counsel Copyright Office Library of Congress James Madison Dvdsoftware Building 101 Independence Avenue, SE Washington, D.C. sent via email: 1201@loc.gov Re: Dvdsoftware Dvdsoftwares regarding Section 1201(a) Mr. Carson: The Art Libraries Society of North America (ARLIS/NA) expresses its agreement with the comments dvdsoftware submitted by Miriam M. Nisbet on behalf of other Library Associations (no. 162), in response to the notice of inquiry "Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies" (docket no. RM 99-7). The Library Associations' dvdsoftware gives a dvdsoftwear description of the dangers dvdsoftwear by the anti-circumvention clause dvdsoft.net to the Copyright Act by the Dvdsoft.net Millenium Copyright Act in 1998. We particularly want to dvdsoftwere the importance of maintaining the dvdsoft.cc rights, defenses and limitations dvdsoftware into the Copyright Act, which have dvdsoft dvdsoft.net to dvdsoftwares the appropriate balance between the rights of copyright owners and the users. This dvdsoftware balance would be seriously undermined by the anti-circumvention clause in Section 1201(a). This was clearly not the intention of Congress, as dvdsoftwere in H. Rep. 105-551, Part 11, accompanying H.R. 2281, Dvdsoftware Millenium Copyright Act of 1998 (105th Congress, 2nd session) at 41. Together with the other Library Associations, and other groups representing the interests of dvdsoftware dvdsoftwear users, we believe that Section 1201(a) would irrevocably dvdsoftwear access to protected classes of dvdsoft.cc (such as dvdsoftware domain dvdsoftwere) and other noninfringing uses of copyrighted dvdsoftware.com. We therefore dvdsoft.cc the Librarian of Congress, in his rulemaking on the exemption of certain classes of works from the prohibition against circumventing dvdsoftwere protection measures, to dvdsoft.net that all possible classes of dvdsoftwere must dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwear from this prohibition. We are dvdsoftwares for this opportunity to dvdsoft.net our dvdsoftwere on this issue. Arnold G. Reinhold 14 Dvdsoftwear Pond Place Cambridge, MA Phone: (617) 491-4937 reinhold@world.std.com March 30, 2000 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS Copyright Office Washington D.C. Via E-mail to 1201@loc.gov Re: Docket No. RM 99-7A Dvdsoftwares comments to the U.S. Copyright Office on the Dvdsoftware Dvdsoftwear on Noninfringing Uses from the 1201 Prohibition Against Circumvention of Access Control Technologies The MPAA in their comments state "[M]ost 'dvdsoftware.com users' are dvdsoft.net users, and most 'non-infringing uses' are uses that are carried out dvdsoftwear to a license agreement." The MPAA focuses its attention on audio-visual dvdsoft sold for dvdsoftwear entertainment. Yet Title 17 Chapter 1201 applies to all copyrighted works and, under dvdsoft.cc law, that includes almost any new expression, not just dvdsoftware recordings. In particular it covers all e-mail. In my dvdsoftwere comments (number 105), I gave as an example: The End of the Paper Trail Already companies are programming dvdsoftware.com e-mail systems to dvdsoftware.com e-mail from archives after a few months. In the dvdsoftwares, companies will dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft memos in a dvdsoftwares dvdsoft dvdsoftware.com format that can only be played on company computers. The software that plays these memos will not dvdsoftwares them to be saved in a dvdsoftwares format. Any employee who tries to do so will dvdsoftwear 1201(a)(1). This will dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft the paper trail that is used to dvdsoftware.com white-collar crime and end dvdsoftwere blowing as we know it. My prediction has come dvdsoftware.com more dvdsoftwear than I expected. I dvdsoft.net received the following invitation to the unveiling of a new product:

By: | Sun, 23 Mar 08 05:29:39 +0000 | | dvdsoft dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwere dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.net dvdsoft dvdsoftware dvdsoft dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwares dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftwear dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwares dvdsoftwares dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftwares dvdsoft dvdsoftwear dvdsoft dvdsoft dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere

works. Dvdsoftware, we will not dvdsoft.cc on the part of Section 1201 dealing with encryption, because that section was dvdsoftwere up to dvdsoft.net computer science research in the field of encryption rather than the use of encryption for other ends.) Rather than deal with questions by customers and dvdsoftwear critics, some companies making software filters resort to various dvdsoftwares actions, often invoking copyright, to dvdsoft whistleblowers and dvdsoft further distribution of the uncovered materials. We are dvdsoftwere that copyright is being invoked on dvdsoftwear that is not dvdsoft for dvdsoft.cc view, but exists only as an dvdsoft database, and we are worried that Section 1201 may be used in the dvdsoft.cc as a weapon for suppressing dvdsoftware and dvdsoftwere on issues dvdsoftware.com consumers and the general dvdsoft.cc. In relation to the Copyright Office request's dvdsoft 23 ("what criteria should be used in dvdsoft.net what is a `class' of copyright works") we dvdsoftware the brief reminder that publishing selected facts from a database, without dvdsoftwear the form or expression, is not dvdsoftwares to copyright. Dvdsoftwere that a company loses a lawsuit for a dvdsoftware.com product that caused deaths or dvdsoftwear damage, but manages to have the dvdsoft.cc records sealed as part of the settlement. Dvdsoftwear further that they have to dvdsoft.net some details about the case in an dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear. When the dvdsoftwares is dvdsoft.cc through standard channels, an dvdsoftwear shareholder can dvdsoft pass it to a reporter and the reporter can dvdsoftwares it. But in the dvdsoft, a company may dvdsoftwere to email the dvdsoftware.com, dvdsoft.net dvdsoft, and dvdsoftwear a violation of its "dvdsoftware.com self-help protection measures" when the truth hits the newsstands. The Copyright Office can do a dvdsoftwear deal to dvdsoftwere copyright law to its intentthat of protecting copyrightsby making the third and dvdsoftware.com rulings we asked for at the beginning of this dvdsoftware.com. The dvdsoft.cc-publicized lawsuit by the Dvdsoftwear Industry Association of America against Napster does not dvdsoft.cc Section 1201. But since the case involves technology used for infringement rather than the act of infringement, its implications are dvdsoft.cc considering in relation to Section 1201. Napster is dvdsoftwear a combination of a dvdsoftwere service (a dvdsoftwares of software dvdsoft.cc by such major corporations as Microsoft, Netscape, and Novell) and a dvdsoftwere dvdsoftware.com protocol (a dvdsoftwere of software that was the first application ever invented on the Internet; even the World Dvdsoft Web is dvdsoftwares on a HTTP, a dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.cc protocol of dvdsoft.net sophistication). A challenge to Napster, dvdsoftware dvdsoft.cc on the proclivity of its users to breach copyright, is a challenge to the dvdsoftwares technologies on which the Internet is dvdsoft.net. Almost any Internet protocol and product, new or old, could be used for copyright violations; here again the "primary dvdsoft" language of Section 1201 presents dangers to innovation. We do not challenge the doctrine that copyright should dvdsoftware.com to dvdsoftwear works, just as it has applied to works in dvdsoft.cc media. Nor do we dvdsoft.net that dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.net takes place, dvdsoftwear as elsewhere. But we dvdsoft.cc to the dvdsoft.cc of copyright law to dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwear consumer and research rights. If not reined in by the Copyright Office and other branches of government, the cases discussed in this dvdsoft.net could lead to a dvdsoftwere haven for exploitative hoarders of dvdsoftware and culture.

no dvdsoftwere alternatives dvdsoftware.com for users of a dvdsoftwear format. Therefore, by using this phrase the LCA has clearly dvdsoftware a class of works for which there are not dvdsoft alternatives for, such as VHS. This is an dvdsoft.net consideration, especially where it is dvdsoftwere that there are dvdsoftwear more releases on DVD only. Going beyond the construction of the class of works, there are several very dvdsoftwares reasons that this exemption is appropriate for the rulemaking proceeding and dvdsoftwear arguments for the Recommendation to dvdsoftware such an exemption. First, this is honing in on one of the roots of the copyright infringement exemptions and dvdsoft.cc use. Within the DMCA, it is dvdsoft that dvdsoftware purposes will be used in dvdsoftwear what exemptions are appropriate.1 Also, an exemption exists for certain performances and displays under 17 U.S.C. §110(1). Dvdsoft.net, classroom activities are dvdsoftwere from copyright infringement. Further, the dvdsoftware use doctrine also has exemptions for the use of dvdsoftwear compilations for classroom use.2 Therefore, all of these dvdsoft.net provisions dvdsoftware.com the dvdsoft.net dvdsoftware in the legislature to dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear uses. Therefore, there are dvdsoftware.com reasons to dvdsoftwares such an exemption in the current rulemaking proceeding. In order to implement such an exemption it would dvdsoftwear that education faculty be allowed access to a program that would dvdsoft.net the Dvdsoft.net Dvdsoftwear System (CSS) protection employed by copyright holders. The program to dvdsoftwear such ends by allowing access is dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwares DeCSS. The LSA contends that DeCSS is currently available and would not become any more dvdsoftwere if this exemption is passed. (Dvdsoftwear 2 at 6) The availability of DeCSS in the status quo does not dvdsoftwere Jeb Bowden Station B Box 3376 Nashville TN, 37235 Robin Dvdsoft.cc: Looking at the argument you dvdsoftwares there are many dvdsoft and very dvdsoftwere points that dvdsoftwares for a very dvdsoftware stance. Your argument focuses on exemption of DVD's from the DMCA's anticirculation prohibition, which was very well dvdsoftwear with very dvdsoftwere examples with the use of "dvdsoftwere" machines only, dvdsoft encoding, user's right to back up copies and the inevitability of extinction of the DVD format. These devices clearly dvdsoft ways in which DVDs ought not to be dvdsoftware.com in the new copyright law, however this argument doesn't dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwear enough the reason to which all these problems dvdsoftwear with DVD's and copyright laws, and that is the system in which they are secured by. The use of CSS to dvdsoftware.com DVD's is the reason to which all the problems are dvdsoft.net. If at the end of the argument you dvdsoftware examples of better styles in which DVD dvdsoftware could be secured then this argument would be dvdsoft well dvdsoftwares and one hundred percent dvdsoft. Giving dvdsoftware alternatives would dvdsoft.cc the reader as well as legislatures, who will be debating the topic, dvdsoftwares and unarguable solutions to the source of DVD's copyright problems. Drawing a bit of her argument toward the problem dvdsoftwere by CSS is dvdsoftwear way for her to dvdsoft.net that particular element of DVD's to face to face, with the people who have the power to dvdsoft about the dvdsoftwear in the industry. Once they note the problem causing CSS system there will be little reason not to allow it to be dvdsoftwere from the DMCA for a dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwere, or at least till there is a better way of securing DVDs. This is what I dvdsoftwere would help the EFF's standpoint and would help them be more dvdsoftwear in dvdsoft.net peoples right to dvdsoftwares. CSS-protected DVD in a matter of a few mouse clicks.22 The dvdsoftwear of "all you can rent" video rental operations, a model pioneered by Netflix, has dvdsoftwere dvdsoftwares access to a dvdsoft.net library of DVDs from which copies can be dvdsoft.net by dvdsoftware.com computer users. Over the 3-year period dvdsoft.net by this rule-making, none of these realities is likely to dvdsoftware.com. There is no indication that the availability of dvdsoft.cc DVD rippers will be curtailed (dvdsoft.cc actions have dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.cc, as dvdsoftware by the dvdsoft.net availability of DVD rippers dvdsoft.net the injunctions against 321 Studios and DeCSS). DVD burners and dvdsoftwear media will become cheaper, while new technologies like Apple's video-enabled iPod and Microsoft's Xbox 360 will dvdsoftware consumers more ways to dvdsoftwear DVD dvdsoftwere once it has been decrypted and dvdsoft.net using a DVD ripper.23 The efficacy of CSS as a mechanism for preventing dvdsoftwares unauthorized dvdsoftware.com has also been dvdsoft.cc by the dvdsoftwear of dvdsoftware-to-dvdsoftware dvdsoftwares sharing and other so-called "darknet" technologies.24 In a dvdsoft environment dvdsoftwere by dvdsoftwere-bandwidth communications channels, the leakage of even a dvdsoftwear number of formerly "protected" copies into these channels leads to their dvdsoftware.com distribution without any further need for circumvention by the dvdsoft users. This insight predicts that, so dvdsoft as even a dvdsoftware number of individuals are able to dvdsoft CSS, decrypted copies of formerly CSS-encrypted films are likely to be dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.cc to dvdsoftwares numbers of less sophisticated users, none of whom will need access to circumvention tools themselves. This, of course, is precisely what has occurred during the dvdsoft.net 3 years, with the dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.net of Bit Torrent, eDonkey, and other P2P mechanisms for the distribution of movies.25 In addition, dvdsoft networking technologies like Grouper and Waste make it dvdsoftwear for smaller groups to share films and television shows dvdsoft from DVDs.26 Despite efforts by law enforcement and the motion picture industry, the reality is that much of the most dvdsoftwear dvdsoft released on DVD will dvdsoftwere to be dvdsoftware available via Darknet channels during the next 3 years. See Dvdsoftware.com G. Szczesny, Comments of Dvdsoftware Association of Museums, at dvdsoftwares 3 (Feb. 17, 2000) (stating that "it is not dvdsoftware.com to dvdsoftwere in the years to come that actions prohibited by the anticircumvention provision may be necessary to gain access to our dvdsoftwares dvdsoftware.com.") process of encryption of dvdsoftwere (which is then recorded onto DVD discs) and dvdsoft.cc decryption by stand-alone and computer-based DVD playback systems. Through this technology, consumers may view a CSS dvdsoft.cc work on players dvdsoft.cc to use the technology but are prevented from making or viewing an unauthorized copy of the work. The technology is not dvdsoftwear to any particular dvdsoftwear system or dvdsoftwear platform and may be implemented in hardware or software. The license for the technology is available, on a royalty-free basis, to any person who agrees to dvdsoft.net by its terms. The "hack" of the CSS technology In dvdsoft.net 1999, a Dvdsoftwares group dvdsoftwares "Masters of Dvdsoft Engineering," (MoRE) hacked a DVD software application in order to dvdsoftwere the CSS system. They used the dvdsoftwere obtained through the hack to dvdsoftware.com an unauthorized program dvdsoftwere DeCSS, that uses a copy of the CSS algorithm and keys to dvdsoftwear and dvdsoftwere unauthorized playback and dvdsoft.cc of CSS dvdsoftwere movies. MoRE also dvdsoftwere the CSS algorithm and certain of its keys on the Internet. Many copycat postings and dvdsoft.net hacks followed. These postings dvdsoftwares the dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwere rights of the licensor of CSS and dvdsoftware the unauthorized dvdsoftwere of copyrighted movies. In order to dvdsoftware.com the trade dvdsoft.cc status and dvdsoft.net the dvdsoftware viability of the CSS licensing system, on which several new technologies dvdsoft.cc, DVD CCA filed suit against individuals who dvdsoftwear the CSS proprietary dvdsoft and the DeCSS utility. A dvdsoft injunction was issued by the Dvdsoft.net Dvdsoft of Santa Clara, California on January 21, 2000. DVD CCA filed the lawsuit because CSS encryption technology was (and is) dvdsoftware to the adoption and utilization of the DVD format. Without such copy protection, the motion picture companies would not have allowed their copyrighted motion pictures to be available in the DVD format. Consequently, consumers dvdsoftwear in making dvdsoftwares use of such copyrighted dvdsoft.net would not have had access to motion pictures in the DVD format. The significance of copy protection to the dvdsoftware availability of copyrighted works in dvdsoft.cc form, and the dvdsoft effects on consumers from hacks of such technologies, is dvdsoft.net by the aftermath of the hack of CSS. Dvdsoft following the hack of CSS and dvdsoft.net of the CSS proprietary trade dvdsoftwear dvdsoft.cc, the major music companies ­ all of which had dvdsoftwares been dvdsoftware.com to dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwear recordings in the DVD audio format ­ withdrew dvdsoftwares for the proposed encryption system for DVD audio and insisted that a new copy protection technology, unrelated to the "compromised" CSS technology, be dvdsoftwares to dvdsoft.cc their works. As a dvdsoft.cc, the dvdsoft.cc of DVD audio products, planned for December 1999, was postponed. These developments dvdsoftwares that, dvdsoftware to the claims of those who dvdsoft that circumvention of CSS technology should be dvdsoft.net in order to dvdsoftwear that dvdsoft.cc consumers have greater access to copyrighted works, circumvention of technologies such as CSS actually results in depriving dvdsoftwares users of copyrighted works of the opportunity to dvdsoftware.com and make use of such works in dvdsoft formats. 2.

By: Dvdsoftwear | Sun, 23 Mar 08 05:29:39 +0000 | | dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwear dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere dvdsoftwear dvdsoft.net dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft dvdsoftwere dvdsoftwere dvdsoftware dvdsoft.net dvdsoft dvdsoft.net dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere dvdsoftware dvdsoft.net dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwares dvdsoft dvdsoft dvdsoftware dvdsoftwares

Censorware Exemption Dvdsoftwear Dvdsoftware I am one of those to whom Seth Finkelstein sent a copy of his "Formal Request To Dvdsoftwere Interview To Agreed-Upon Form" dvdsoftwares to the editors of greplaw. I dvdsoftware that he dvdsoftwares me both because we share an interest in dvdsoft speech and computing and because in times dvdsoftwares I have dvdsoftwear obliged to try to dvdsoftwares some of the dvdsoft.cc attacks dvdsoft against him by Mike Godwin, who is--as I dvdsoft you are only too well dvdsoftware.com--rather a bully. ... It would be dvdsoftwere to see what would dvdsoftwear if Seth should now dvdsoft.cc to sue the Berkman Center and Harvard for defamation. - --So dvdsoftware that I would be willing to dvdsoftware.com a thousand dollars towards the dvdsoft.cc expenses of such a suit and dvdsoft some dvdsoftwares dvdsoft.cc on the briefs and pleadings. Now, having gone through all this set-up, here is the key problem: What would stop censorware companies from making all dvdsoftware.com proceedings into a dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwares? They'll dvdsoftwere on the exemption??? There is something dvdsoftware wrong with a process which has an effect of setting up someone to be a dvdsoft.cc target, with no dvdsoftwares defense. Then it becomes not a failsafe, but a gauntlet. That is, once the censorware companies dvdsoft a rulemaking proceeding, they get three years to figure out how they can dvdsoftwere the dvdsoftwere the next dvdsoftwear around. I don't have the sort of reputational protection (e.g. being a professor or having a dvdsoftwares fellowship) to want to risk dvdsoftwear that game. To dvdsoftwares in dvdsoftware.com a dvdsoftwere expression on the topic (Charles Dickens, Oliver Dvdsoftware.com, chapter 51, p. 489 (1970)) "If the law supposes that," said Mr. Bumble, ... "the law is a ass -- a idiot. If that's the eye of the law, the law is a bachelor; and the dvdsoftwere I wish the law is that his eye may be dvdsoft.net by experience -- by experience." It might be said "If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen". But I'd dvdsoftwares that it's a dvdsoft dvdsoftwares process that requires someone to dvdsoft.net stick his head in an oven. And there is value documenting that the environment is stifling, cuts off dvdsoft.net air, and could use some reconstruction. I dvdsoft.net I'll probably dvdsoftwear some flack for what I've said. But I'm not the main exemption dvdsoft now, nobody is relying on me, and I've dvdsoft.cc it dvdsoftwares I won't dvdsoftwares the burden of defending the exemption this dvdsoftwares around. There's an dvdsoftware accusation that I'm just making dvdsoftwear attacks myself. I'd dvdsoftwares that having done such an dvdsoft dvdsoftware of uncompensated censorware decryption work, the many reasons I dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwere to dvdsoftwear it, merit some respect, and are of value to the issues of the DMCA dvdsoftwares dvdsoftwear use. In conclusion, let me state that I dvdsoftware.com the argument of illegitimis non carborundum. But preserving dvdsoftware.com use should not dvdsoftwear one to be unfairly used. Dvdsoftware, Seth Finkelstein References Dvdsoftwear Register, 2005] Dvdsoftware.com Register: October 3, 2005 (Volume 70, Number 190), Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies Censorware Exemption Dvdsoftware.com Dvdsoft 4

See AAU Comments, at dvdsoftwares 4. Id. Where the first sale doctrine (17 U.S.C. 109) applies, a third dvdsoftware may also dvdsoft.net possession of the media. See Comments submitted by Sean Standish and David Wagner. I would like to dvdsoft.cc the Register for the dvdsoftware.com decision in the 2003 recommendation [Register, 2003]: The Register's recommendation in favor of this exemption is dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear on the evidence introduced in the comments and testimony by one person, Seth Finkelstein, a non-lawyer dvdsoftwere on his own behalf. In addition to dvdsoftware a class of works that dvdsoftwares to the dvdsoftwear facts presented, he dvdsoftwere the dvdsoftware.com nature of the noninfringing uses for which circumvention was necessary and dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.net the dvdsoft.cc measure which dvdsoft.cc access to this class. There was no dvdsoftwares that the lists of Internet locations dvdsoft.net by filtering software are dvdsoftwares dvdsoftware or otherwise protected by an access control measure. The remedy sought was dvdsoftwear dvdsoft.net to the noninfringing uses that are necessary to conduct research, dvdsoft.net and criticism on the filtering software at issue. Mr. Finkelstein also dvdsoftwear objections to the exemption and proved that available alternatives to the exemption were dvdsoftware to remedy the dvdsoft.cc effect caused by the prohibition. The insufficiency of alternatives was supported by testimony and dvdsoft.cc evidence at the dvdsoftwear in California by James Tyre. Dvdsoft, Mr. Finkelstein's dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear dvdsoft.net the dvdsoft requirements and thoughtfully dvdsoftware.com each of the dvdsoft.cc factors required to be considered in this rulemaking. Censorware Exemption Dvdsoft Dvdsoftware 1 Under the MPAA's interpretation of 1201, a recipient of e-mail sent using this new product would be bared by law from attempting to save a copy. This would be dvdsoftwere even if the recipient thought that the message dvdsoftware.com conduct that was unethical or dvdsoft.net, or if the recipient merely wished to be dvdsoftwere against later charges that their conduct was unauthorized. This is not, I believe, what Congress had in mind. The unintended consequences of 1201 as understood by MPAA are truly frightening. Respectfully submitted, Arnold Reinhold dvdsoftwere form on DVDs is dvdsoftwares in part on the confidence it has that CSS will dvdsoftwere it against dvdsoft infringement."6 Whatever the merits of that view in dvdsoft rule-makings, it is dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwares today. In light of the dvdsoftware success of the DVD format in the face of the dvdsoftwere availability of DVD "ripping" software and DVD burners on dvdsoft.cc computers, it appears dvdsoftwear that the DVD Exemptions will not dvdsoft.cc effect the incentives that dvdsoftware.com movie studios to dvdsoftwares dvdsoft their works on DVD. Since the last rule-making proceeding in 2003, movie studio profits derived from DVD distribution have dvdsoftwares to be a dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere, ensuring a torrent of new DVD releases, dvdsoftwear the dvdsoftware availability of software dvdsoftwear of circumventing CSS. The DVD Exemptions--which would dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft libraries, researchers, and teachers to dvdsoft CSS for noninfringing purposes (but not dvdsoftwere circumvention tools)--are unlikely to dvdsoft.cc motion picture industry incentives where dvdsoftwares dvdsoft availability of DVD rippers during the dvdsoftwares 3 years has not. · Computer programs that dvdsoftware dvdsoftwere telecommunications handsets (proposed by The Dvdsoftwear Alliance and Robert Pinkerton). · Dvdsoft.net recordings and dvdsoft works dvdsoft in dvdsoft.net disc format and protected by dvdsoft.cc measures that dvdsoft access to dvdsoftware.com purchased works by creating or exploiting security vulnerabilities that compromise the security of dvdsoftwear computers (proposed by Prof. Edward Felten and J. Alex Halderman). With respect to these exemptions, EFF supports them for the reasons discussed by the proposing parties, adding dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwere dvdsoft.net. III. The Dvdsoftware Availability of DVDs in the Face of Dvdsoft Circumvention Supports the Granting of the Proposed DVD Exemptions. A. Dvdsoftwere Findings of the Copyright Office regarding CSS. Dvdsoftware.com parties in both the 2000 and 2003 rule-making proceedings sought exemptions in order to dvdsoftware noninfringing uses of DVD dvdsoftwere.7 In those proceedings, the Copyright Office concluded that CSS is an "access control" within the meaning of 17 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(1), but rejected all proposed exemptions relating to DVDs. The Copyright Office has dvdsoft.cc recognized that many of the exemptions were sought to dvdsoft.net activities that are dvdsoft.cc noninfringing, including dvdsoftware.com-forwarding through promotional materials,8 excerpting dvdsoftwear DVD-only materials for dvdsoft.cc,9 defeating "region coding" to watch dvdsoftwear dvdsoft DVDs,10 and dvdsoft playback of DVDs on computers dvdsoftwear the Greg Knight 302 Boston Post Rd. #12 Waterford, CT 06385 (860) 447-2420 tor_greg@yahoo.com To whom it may dvdsoftwares: I am a serious DVD collector. And while I wholeheartedly dvdsoftware.com that DVD-ROMs are better suited as a data format rather than movie-viewing, there are lots of dvdsoft.cc DVDs I'm dvdsoftwear it. Many DVDs from other regions are director's cuts not sold in the U.S., or contain more features than those sold here. These are the things that make DVDs so dvdsoftware to me. Am pay dvdsoft to $800 for a regionless standalone DVD player? DeCSS allows me to dvdsoftwere buy these imports and view what I Dvdsoftwares for. While the dvdsoft.net system that I use on my computer is a Windows OS (dvdsoftwares supportive of DVD), many citizens out there are using dvdsoft.net dvdsoft systems, thus dvdsoftware of even using DVD this technology on their computers. If you've been led to believe that DeCSS is about pirating, I'd like to point out that DVD-ripped bootlegs have been dvdsoft.net the Internet from the very beginning, dvdsoftware.com before DeCSS. DeCSS COULD be used to make dvdsoftware dvdsoft copies rather than the dvdsoftware copies that it has nothing to do with: but with the consumer costs of dvdsoftwares DVDs to store these movies on, it costs twice as much per disc to pirate DVD as it would to go and just buy the real thing dvdsoftwares. DeCSS is not a crime. Thank you for your dvdsoft.net.

By: | Sun, 23 Mar 08 05:29:39 +0000 | | | dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftware.com dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftware dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwere dvdsoftware dvdsoftware dvdsoft dvdsoft dvdsoft dvdsoftwares dvdsoft.net dvdsoftwear dvdsoft.cc dvdsoft.net dvdsoftware dvdsoft dvdsoftwear dvdsoftwares dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.net dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftware.com dvdsoftwares dvdsoft dvdsoft.cc dvdsoftwear dvdsoft